Classic Washington architecture and thoughtful updates come together in this beautifully maintained 1940 brick Colonial in American University Park. Set on a landscaped corner lot, this home offers an inviting sense of place, with mature plantings, winding flagstone paths, and bright interiors designed for both everyday living and entertaining.
The main level blends traditional character with modern comfort. Formal living and dining rooms feature rich hardwood floors and timeless architectural detail, while a fireplace adds warmth to the living space. An inviting sun porch is ideal as a home office, reading room, or lounge, and a separate family room with handsome built-ins provides another comfortable place to gather. The galley kitchen has been refreshed with new quartz countertops and luxury vinyl plank flooring and opens to an adjacent eat-in area. A full bath on this level adds flexibility. (Note, the family room could be used as a main level bedroom if needed or desired).
Upstairs, the expansive primary suite feels like a private retreat, with vaulted ceilings, two walk-in closets, a separate sitting room, and an en-suite bath with jetted tub and separate stall shower. Two additional bedrooms and a hall bath complete the second level. A third-floor bonus room offers even more versatility for a home office, studio, exercise room, playroom, or quiet getaway.
The lower level extends the living space with a family room centered around a second fireplace and accented by warm wood paneling. New luxury vinyl plank flooring gives the space a fresh foundation, while a large adjoining storage and utility area includes the washer and dryer.
Outdoors, the wrought-iron-fenced corner setting has a garden-like feel, with mature landscaping and meandering flagstone pathways creating inviting spaces to enjoy the outdoors. An attached garage with EV charging, plus additional driveway parking, adds rare convenience in Northwest DC.
Significant 2026 improvements include a new roof, furnace, main air-conditioning system, quartz kitchen countertops, LVP flooring in the kitchen and lower level, carpet stair runners, and fresh interior and exterior paint.
The setting is equally compelling. American University Park—better known as AU Park—is prized for its tree-lined streets, classic homes, green spaces, and convenient access to Tenleytown, Friendship Heights, Spring Valley, and City Ridge. Nearby amenities include Friendship Park, known locally as Turtle Park, the Tenley-Friendship Neighborhood Library, American University’s Katzen Arts Center and AU Museum, Wegmans at City Ridge, neighborhood dining and shopping, and the Tenleytown-AU and Friendship Heights Red Line Metro stations.
With its classic Colonial character, flexible interior spaces, landscaped corner setting, garage and driveway parking, and substantial recent updates, this home offers a distinctive opportunity to enjoy one of Northwest Washington’s most desirable residential neighborhoods.
There are neighborhoods that are desirable, and then there are neighborhoods that quietly define an entire city.
American University Park belongs in the latter category.
For nearly a century, this enclave in Northwest Washington has attracted diplomats, professors, physicians, attorneys, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and families who appreciate that true luxury isn't found in excess—it's found in permanence. Mature tree canopies. Timeless architecture. Exceptional schools. Walkable streets where neighbors know one another by name. It's a place where generations choose to stay, and where homes rarely become available without attracting considerable attention.
Unlike many urban neighborhoods that have reinvented themselves over time, American University Park has remained remarkably true to its original character. Brick Colonials, Cape Cods, and Tudor homes built during the 1920s and 1930s still line quiet streets shaded by mature oaks and maples, creating one of Washington's most enduring residential landscapes. Thoughtful renovations and tasteful additions have modernized many homes while preserving the architectural integrity that continues to define the neighborhood today.
Life here unfolds at a noticeably different rhythm.
Mornings begin with a walk beneath a canopy of mature trees, coffee from Bluestone Lane or Compass Coffee, and perhaps a stop at the historic Wagshal's Market—a neighborhood institution that has served residents for generations. Weekends bring children's laughter at Turtle Park, walks through nearby Rock Creek Park, evenings at the Katzen Arts Center, and spontaneous conversations with neighbors while tending gardens or relaxing on front porches.
It is remarkably easy to forget that the White House, Capitol Hill, and downtown Washington are only minutes away.
That rare balance between urban accessibility and residential tranquility is precisely what has made American University Park one of the District's most enduring addresses.
American University Park wasn't designed around trends.
It was built around craftsmanship.
Original brick façades, slate walkways, hardwood floors, elegant proportions, and gracious front porches create a neighborhood with remarkable visual consistency. While each residence tells its own story, together they form one of Washington's most cohesive collections of classic American architecture.
The result is a streetscape that feels timeless rather than fashionable—an increasingly rare quality in today's housing market.
Few neighborhoods offer the ability to leave the car at home without sacrificing convenience.
Residents enjoy effortless access to neighborhood cafés, local restaurants, boutique shopping, parks, grocery markets, and cultural institutions. Wisconsin Avenue, Massachusetts Avenue, Spring Valley, Tenleytown, Friendship Heights, and American University itself are all woven naturally into everyday life, creating a lifestyle where errands become pleasant walks rather than planned outings.
The Tenleytown–AU and Friendship Heights Metro stations provide direct access across the District and beyond, while Georgetown, Bethesda, Capitol Hill, Reagan National Airport, and downtown Washington remain comfortably within reach.
American University Park has long been recognized as one of Washington's premier residential neighborhoods, and for good reason.
Outstanding public schools, respected private school options, exceptionally high homeownership, limited inventory, and a deeply established community have consistently supported long-term desirability. Buyers are drawn not only by the architecture and location, but by the confidence that comes from investing in a neighborhood whose appeal has proven remarkably resilient through changing markets and generations alike.
The finest neighborhoods are measured not simply by their homes, but by how they make everyday life feel.
American University Park offers quiet streets without isolation, city access without congestion, architectural character without compromise, and a genuine sense of community that has become increasingly uncommon in major metropolitan areas.
It is a neighborhood where history is preserved, where investment is rewarded, and where arriving home feels like coming to one of Washington's most distinguished residential addresses.
No agents assigned to this property.
4535 Butterworth Pl NW,
Share this property on:
Message Sent